When it comes to supernatural comedies for teens, few shows struck the perfect balance between humor, horror, and heart quite like My Babysitter’s a Vampire. What began as a small Canadian TV movie quickly grew into a fan-favorite series that charmed audiences across North America with its witty writing, creative storytelling, and lovable characters. Years later, the show still holds a special place in the hearts of fans who grew up watching it.
Origins: From TV Movie to Fan-Favorite Series
My Babysitter’s a Vampire started as a television movie in 2010, produced by Fresh TV, the same Canadian company behind hits like 6teen and Total Drama Island. The movie premiered on Teletoon in Canada and later aired on Disney Channel in the United States, where it quickly became a surprise hit among young audiences.
The success of the movie led to the creation of a TV series in 2011, expanding on the story and characters introduced in the original film. The blend of supernatural adventure and relatable high school comedy made it stand out from other kids’ shows at the time.
Plot Overview
At its core, My Babysitter’s a Vampire tells the story of Ethan Morgan, an ordinary teenager whose parents hire a babysitter named Sarah, only for him to discover she’s actually a vampire — but one who’s trying to live a normal life.
Ethan and his best friend Benny, a nerdy aspiring wizard, soon find themselves caught up in a world filled with vampires, zombies, witches, and other supernatural creatures. Along with their tough and loyal friend Rory — who later becomes a vampire himself — the group faces all kinds of supernatural chaos in their hometown of Whitechapel.
Together, they battle dark forces, solve mysteries, and try to survive high school — often with hilarious and unpredictable results.
Main Characters
- Ethan Morgan (Matthew Knight): A smart but awkward teen who discovers he has visions that allow him to see supernatural events before they happen. His bravery and loyalty make him the heart of the group.
- Sarah (Vanessa Morgan): The “babysitter” and reluctant vampire who tries to protect Ethan and his friends from the dangers of the supernatural world. Her mix of toughness and kindness made her a fan favorite.
- Benny Weir (Atticus Mitchell): Ethan’s best friend and a self-taught spellcaster. His love for magic and quick sense of humor add fun and energy to the group’s adventures.
- Rory Keaner (Cameron Kennedy): The comic relief — goofy, lovable, and always in over his head, especially after becoming a vampire himself.
- Erica Jones (Kate Todd): Sarah’s friend and a full-fledged vampire who embraces her powers and adds drama (and sass) to the team dynamic.
Each character brought something unique to the story, creating a group dynamic that felt both funny and genuine.
Themes and Style
What made My Babysitter’s a Vampire so memorable was its ability to mix genres. It combined teen comedy, fantasy, and light horror, creating a style that appealed to both younger and older audiences.
The show never took itself too seriously — it often poked fun at vampire clichés while still delivering exciting action scenes and emotional moments. Its themes of friendship, courage, and self-discovery resonated with viewers who were navigating their own “monsters” in adolescence.
Visually, it had a playful, slightly spooky aesthetic — think Buffy the Vampire Slayer meets Scooby-Doo, but with a modern, tongue-in-cheek twist.
Reception and Legacy
Though My Babysitter’s a Vampire only ran for two seasons (2011–2012), it built a dedicated fanbase that remains active even years after the show ended. Fans praised its sharp humor, clever writing, and likable cast.
The show also stood out for its Canadian charm — it managed to blend Hollywood-style adventure with the creativity and humor of Canadian television.
Many viewers have called for a revival or continuation, and the cast has often expressed appreciation for the long-lasting fan love. Even today, reruns and streaming have introduced new audiences to the series, proving that its appeal endures.
Impact and Cultural Significance
My Babysitter’s a Vampire arrived during a time when vampire stories were at their peak — the Twilight movies and The Vampire Diaries were dominating pop culture. However, instead of going the dark, romantic route, this series took a comedic and family-friendly approach, making it stand out in a crowded genre.
It also helped launch the careers of its talented cast — most notably Vanessa Morgan, who later became well-known for her role as Toni Topaz on Riverdale.
Conclusion
My Babysitter’s a Vampire remains one of those rare shows that balanced laughs, scares, and heart with effortless charm. It captured the fun of supernatural storytelling without losing its sense of humor or its emotional grounding.